Landlord flouting the spirit of the tenancy deposit legislation says Judge
16th November 2009
There is new tenancy deposit case report in the November issue the Legal Action Magazine, Da Costa v. Pinter, which took place at Bromley County Court in April 2009.
Here the tenancy agreement provided for a monthly rent of £1,950 but also stated 'Payment required in advance of £4,200'. The agents invoice described £2,250 of this sum as a deposit, and at the end of the tenancy the tenants asked for it back. As it was not forthcoming they issued county court proceedings for its return and also claimed the fine of three times the deposit sum. The deposit was then protected, after the issue of proceedings.
The Judge (District Judge Burn) accepted that the sum paid was a deposit and awarded the claimants the deposit money and the fine of £6,750. However the interesting part of this case is the quote from the Judge:
"The purpose of the Act is to try to ensure that landlords secure tenancy deposits in a recognised deposit scheme at the start of the tenancy, so that the deposit can be returned to tenants quickly when the tenancy ends, and that disputes about the deposit can be resolved under the schemes' procedures without the need for court proceedings.
Landlords who describe a deposit as something else, who do not secure it promptly in a deposit scheme as required by the Act, then fail to return the deposit when the tenant leaves (especially if this is without good cause, thereby forcing the tenant to start court proceedings to recover the money) but who then at the last minute after the tenant issues proceedings, pay the deposit into a scheme, are clearly flouting the spirit of the legislation and, on my interpretation, the letter also.
If the s213 and s214 remedies are not applied in a case such as the instant one, the Act would be rendered virtually toothless when landlords flout its provisions."
To view the rest of this article - and thousands like it - become a Gold member today...
The page you are attempting to view is only available to Gold Members
Sorry, you cannot access the page requested as this is for Gold Members only but you can upgrade to our full Membership and gain entry to all our webpages, videos, downloads & products for as little as £11.99 per month or at our lowest price £99.99 for the year!
Just click here to Go Gold Today!
With brand new eBooks and spreadsheet software as well as existing downloadable favourites and full website roaming including video footage and our monthly Gold Members PDF Magazine - Gold Membership will also ensure you have first say on all our latest property investment opportunities with new deals sent exclusively to your inbox prior to website launch. This puts you in the driving seat and one step ahead as you aim to build your portfolio!
Add to that our latest incentive offers you a FREE monthly magazine - delivered to your doorstep direct!
Your Property Network Magazine - RRP £4.95 per issue will be delivered to your door once every four weeks for every month of your Property Secrets Gold Membership - 100% FREE OF CHARGE - No clause!!
So Join today and get full website access and all our fantastic offers - for more information or to subscribe now just click here
Here's what you will get!
- Ask an Expert Support - online access to all our experts, ask unlimited questions to our Mortgage Brokers, Tax Advisors, Currency Specialists, Overseas Agents and much more...
- Exclusive Deals - brand new property opportunities emailed directly to you as soon as they arrive - prior to website launch.
- PSonProperty - exclusive content from Alan Forsyth and the team on buying investment property in the UK & Overseas.
- Property Auction News - new listings and top hints from Peter Parfait's famous subscription only magazine Property Auction News.
- Videos - exclusive viewing including partner videos and live feeds with access to eight Property Secrets tv channels.
- Downloads - full spreadsheet software including buy to let calculators, property indexes, mortgage calculators and more...
- Gold Magazine - our monthly newsletter highlights news articles, up coming events, latest deals and exclusive offers to all our full members.
- Expert written eBooks & Guides - worth well over £250 - these fully downloadable eBooks cover a wide range of subjects from property renovation & auction property to buy to let strategy and buying overseas.
- Free YPN subscription - A hard copy of Your Property Network Magazine delivered to your doorstep every four weeks of your Gold Membership.
All the above and much more - bringing you more than ever before for your Gold Membership!!
Just click here for our various membership offers including monthly, quarterly, semiannually and yearly products!
