|
Made in America - What the global slowdown means for CEE – and for property investors
|
| The media love nothing more than a good horror story. And a horror story that's coming to a street near you is the very best kind.
No surprise then that they're having a field day with the current economic crisis.
But we can't really claim the media is exaggerating this time.
However much they might love the script, the fact is it doesn't change one bit that we are on the verge of a slowdown - maybe even a recession in the US.
When the Fed cuts the prime rate 125 basis points in a matter of a few days, something serious is going on.
And for all the talk of decoupling - in other words Asia and all the developing economies being able to carry on relatively unaffected by a recession in the US - we can see now that at least stock investors think that's hooey.
Decoupling myth We see bad news emerge form the US and the stock markets plunge from Wall Street to Warsaw to Hong Kong.
The consumer markets in China and India are now huge and they may well be able to absorb some of the slack left as the US slows, but the world's biggest economy still hold sway.
It still accounts for over 22% of the entire world economy, according to World Bank estimates. Japan, plus Germany, France, Italy, Spain and the UK, account for around an additional 24%.
So, the big economies DO matter because they are where the customers still are.
US consumers spent about $9.5 trillion in 2007 - almost 600% more than Chinese and Indian consumers put together.
Biggest consumer base on earth If the biggest customer base on earth starts to contract, we're all going to feel it.
The question then for property investors in central and Eastern Europe is not IF there's a slowdown - there WILL be one, but instead: How much will this slowdown hit these economies AND what effect is that going to have on their property markets?
Surprisingly, perhaps, and despite recent headlines based on forecasts from the World Bank and the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, the effects are likely actually to be mostly benign.
We can say this for two fundamental reasons:
1) The key economies (by which I mean those PS has targeted as the best for property investors - Slovakia, Romania, Poland, Bulgaria and Czech) are incredibly strong going into the slowdown. So, we'll see a slowing of growth, but it will not be excessive.
2) A slowing of GDP growth and consumer driven growth is exactly what many of these economies - especially Romania and Bulgaria - urgently need. Basically a slowdown was coming anyway. This way it may well come before we see markets (property markets as well as whole economies) becoming dangerously over-heated.
(Obviously, if the US does go into a deep and prolonged recession and drags much of the rest of the global economy down with it - a sort of 'Richard's armageddon' scenario, for those who follow his forum posts - then nowhere will be immune and nothing we're invested in, probably not even gold. In this case, we'll all just have to simply sit out the cold hard economic winter.)
But how likely is that? Very unlikely.
We've already looked at the effects of a slowdown on FDI into CEE.
But it's worth taking a moment to realise how fast these economies are actually growing.
Huge growth Poland's economy grew at 6.5% in 2007, the fastest for a decade. Romania will be somewhere around 6%. Bulgaria is expected to be 6.2%. The Czech Republic around 6%. And the truly outstanding Slovak Republic is expected to have grown by 9% in 2007.
These are very, very impressive figures and a measure of just how much growth momentum there is in these economies. But with such pace (usually, at least) come some negatives, most notably inflation and current account deficits, which of course have to be financed somehow.
And just as the mighty US deficit needs foreign cash to support it, so do those CEE economies with big deficits. That cash is likely to become increasingly harder to attract as investors look for safety. That means it'll cost more.
(Slovakia might seem the odd man out here, with great growth and under control inflation AND a healthy current account. But Slovakia too needs customers for all those cars its turning out).
We've already seen some of the effects of this as some CEE currencies have weakened - the leu in particular is down around 20% against the euro in six months. If you're a Romanian with a euro linked mortgage, that can't help but hurt.
Sounds bad?
Well, not so terrible actually.
Let's put things into perspective.
The European Bank for Reconstruction and Development has cut its 2008 growth forecast for eastern Europe to 5.0-5.5% from 6.1% entirely due to the global credit crisis.
5.5% GDP growth is hardly a disaster! Even 5% growth would be great.
Put it into context - let's be optimistic and assume the UK makes 1.5% this year. What about the US? 1.5%, 1%? Anyone's guess really - but few would bet on much more. Germany, France - are they really likely to do better than 1.5%? Italy will barely register any growth. And Spain's GDP growth rate is almost certain to plummet.
Suddenly 5% sounds pretty fine!
And the EBRD points out in its forecast this week something we at PS have long argued:
That these economies ...'... are less vulnerable than other emerging economies because they benefit from the extra economic security offered by European Union membership. Investors assume greater risks than elsewhere because membership brings clear development perspectives and outside financial scrutiny.'
Bingo!
That's the key difference with these markets.
And it's the one that we (sound of own trumpets blowing) said way back in 2003 (when Eastern European Property Secrets was first published) would make all the difference to property investors.
Here's a demonstration of how important this key strength it is in concrete terms.
In 2008 Romania will receive almost $1.5 billion in EU structural funds to improve its infrastructure. A massive sum.
And this, it's fair to say, is the kind of backing that last year drew net investments of €460 million into the country's stocks and bonds markets - more than twice the previous year's net sum.
Overall, foreigners bought €2.36 billion worth of Romanian stocks and bonds, up from €1.123 billion the year before. And the net the balance shows people and funds are buying and keeping their money in.
Turbo-charged growth is seen everywhere you look.
Mortgage penetration rates relative to GDP in all these countries might still be low, but they are growing at staggering rates of 50% and more.
Bulgaria's mortgage market grew by 64% in 2007. The size of Poland's market increased by 50%. The Czech market grew in value by 41%, year-on-year, in 2007.
When you see growth rates of this ilk - doubling, even 50% growth - it's almost certainly time for a period of more measured growth.
Slowdown needed
So, a slowdown of a few percentage points in overall GDP growth is - it's worth repeating - exactly what most of these economies need.
A slowdown will allow the Polish government to continue saying 'no' to inflationary wage demands from public workers, as it is currently doing.
A slowdown will enable the huge wage rises we've seen in some sectors of the Romanian economy slow and fall more in line with raised productivity, allowing the country to be competitive on salaries for longer.
And, if a few hundred thousand Romanians return home from Spain and Italy because work dries up there for them, then this will also help cool wage inflation. The same is true of Poles in the UK or Holland or Ireland.
Sure, this probably will slow the huge growth we've seen in property prices - but how much more healthy and stable it is in the longer term.
Bucharest's finance ministry forecasts GDP growth of 5.9% until 2010, but the trend will be gradually downward.
Here's what it says about this growth: '...against the background of improved internal and external economic competitiveness, which will result in a high export pace, in production matching better demand and in reducing the share of the current account deficit within GDP.'
I think that's what everyone else calls 'sustainable growth'.
And that for property investors, eyeing the longer term, is far better than a blistering pace right now.
|
|
POSTED BY
ROBIN BOWMAN
ON
THU 31ST JANUARY
AT
13:01 GMT
|
|
[ Back To Blog Home ]
|
MADE IN AMERICA - WHAT THE GLOBAL SLOWDOWN MEANS FOR CEE – AND FOR PROPERTY INVESTORS
[underline]re: Reverse Migration[/underline] Hi Robin You make a very good point that the recent fall of the GBP vs Euro makes the UK a lot less attractive than it once was. In effect this is a 15% reduction in the value of the money that EU migrants are able to send back home from the UK. Of course, the other big people attractors - Ireland, Spain and perhaps Holland - are all inside the Euroland - and only Sweden continues as does the UK outside the Euro. Therefore, the argument for a Pole to go to Ireland or stay at home - rather than head for the UK - is getting stronger. And, I think this will be another dent in UK's growth and will strengthen the central Euroland economies of Germany and Austria - where reform will allow CEE workers to take up employment. Either way, this is a significant way of 're-investing human capital' back into the CEE countries. And, I think again, this is why we are looking a pretty dramatic slow downs in the Western Edge of Europe - but continuing strong (albeit slightly slower) growth in Central and Eastern Europe. The credit crunch and its after effects seem to be less about a total collapse; rather a shift in power and growth from old to new. And, those new / hot locations within the EU have to be the best bet - for precisely the reasons you've set out above. Cheers Neil
|
POSTED BY
NEIL LEWIS
ON
THU 31ST JANUARY
AT
13:21
|
|
RE: MADE IN AMERICA - WHAT THE GLOBAL SLOWDOWN MEANS FOR CEE – AND FOR PROPERTY INVESTORS
Neil I think it's true that the weakness of the pound may put off some Polish would-be migrants. But, my view is that the wages are so much higher in the West that the availability of jobs will have a far greater effect than a weaker exchange rate. That's why I mention slowdowns in Italy and Spain as being important - because, in Spain in particular, so many Romanians are employed in the rapidly constricting construction industry. If a large number return home, that will be no bad thing in economic terms because it could well cool Romanian wage growth. As for the UK in the longer term - again, I think, just as the squeeze is what many CEE economies need, so is a much weaker pound what the UK needs to drive up exports - and that's how the jobs will be created. In the longer run, it's those currencies that stay relatively strong that will start to suffer - that's why I think we'll see the euro rate come down. So, lower euro interest rates and and a bit more inflation. Cheers
|
POSTED BY
ROBIN BOWMAN
ON
THU 31ST JANUARY
AT
14:28
|
|
RE: MADE IN AMERICA - WHAT THE GLOBAL SLOWDOWN MEANS FOR CEE – AND FOR PROPERTY INVESTORS
Hi Interesting to read reports of the World Bank's regular update on the EU8+2 CEE countries. Seems they agree with our take that, these economies are fundamentally strong, have limited and indirect exposure to the credit crisis and where they are exposed - big trade imbalances and high foreign borrowing - a slowdown will actually be a positive because many economies have been growing at unsustainable levels. Here are some excerpts: 'In 2008-2009, the region will take further, albeit shorter steps on its long road of catching-up to the EU15. GDP growth rates have probably peaked in many countries in the first half of 2007, even they remained robust in the second half of the year. This deceleration is likely to continue through 2008. The slowdown is most pronounced in the Baltic countries. Growth should recover gradually in Hungary which has been undergoing a protracted fiscal consolidation and from mid-2007 has been struggling with weak GDP growth and relatively high inflation. In some respects passing through the turning point in the business cycle is a good thing. The rate of growth was clearly unsustainable in some countries, resulting in the buildup of internal and external imbalances. The challenge going forward is to ensure that this turning point marks the entry into a period of orderly adjustments. Success or failure in rising to this challenge will have an important bearing on the ability of the EU8+2 to continue along a steady income convergence path. Current account deficits (CADs) stabilized in the Baltic countries but are still widening in Bulgaria and Romania. These CADs represent the greatest vulnerability to deteriorating international conditions and are particularly worrisome for those countries with high levels of foreign currency debt. The external imbalances may come down in line with slower GDP growth. It is important however to look beyond the immediate market gyrations to see the bigger picture. The ability of the EU8+2 so far to withstand the global turbulence is attributable to several factors. Their banks were not as exposed to the subprime market. Their economies are linked more directly to the EU than the US. While credit has increased rapidly, private borrowers were under-leveraged to start with. Still with expected global slowdown, exports may lessen as a driver of growth. Fiscal adjustments will therefore be needed to bring domestic demand under control. '
|
POSTED BY
ROBIN BOWMAN
ON
MON 4TH FEBRUARY
AT
10:24
|
|
RE: MADE IN AMERICA - WHAT THE GLOBAL SLOWDOWN MEANS FOR CEE – AND FOR PROPERTY INVESTORS
The article is interesting and I wonder if you would comment on the following. The subprime write down to date is around £250 billion, the total sub prime debt written is £1.7 trillion according to a Barclays Economist I met recently in Oxford. Now the economist was not suggesting that all this risk would be taken off balance sheets but it does underline what is left in the closet. If you add to this the new Basle 2 criteria that all european banks have to adhere to when lending in the near future then we can expect higher cost of borrowing. In fact you can see this coming through as the 'buy to let' financing comes with a significant fee. A 2% charge on new 'Buy to Let' funding is not unusual, the actual payback rates are no lower ranging from 0.6 to 1.6% over BOE base. Paragon a large lender in the investment sector is refusing to write any new business at all. Even if supply is low and some parts of europe seem more attractive than the UK, if borrowing costs increase then markets will not move upward. Many large lenders are looking at securitising and hedging their lending to customers as a revenue stream, not just plain old fashion lending. Things will continue to get tougher for longer than we think.
|
POSTED BY
ROB7N
ON
WED 20TH FEBRUARY
AT
04:13
|
|
RE: MADE IN AMERICA - WHAT THE GLOBAL SLOWDOWN MEANS FOR CEE – AND FOR PROPERTY INVESTORS
Hi Rob I don't think there's any doubt lending will be tighter everywhere this year and that pretty much all markets will slow. The point is that in some cases - notably in some CEE economies (and property markets) that will actually be a good thing and just what is needed - at least for the rest of 2008. The Baltics seem to be calming in an orderly fashion (so far), and (so far) there have been no significant attacks on their currencies that have destabilised them. That has to be a good omen. The fact is that, despite some weaknesses, especially current account deficits in some economies, many CEE countries ( Hungary aside for now), still have the best momentum to see them through a tough year or so and their long term potential, which is what really counts, looks as solid as it ever did. As far as the £1.7 trillion figure is concerned - I haven't seen one that high. Seems an unlikely amount though, as it would be over 33% of all US mortgages - the market seems to be regularly estimated at around $10 trillion. But, anyway, where will the next write downs appear? Great piece from the D Telegraph a while back - the storm seems to be moving east.... "There is still $300bn of bad debt out there, and Japan could be hiding most of it. Just as battered investors had begun to glimpse signs of recovery in America, the next shoe has dropped with an almighty thud in Japan. Echoes are rumbling across the Far East. The Tokyo bourse has crumbled, suffering the worst start to the year since the Second World War. The Nikkei index is down 17 per cent since Christmas, and the shares of Japanese banks are leading the slide. Mizuho Financial, Mitsubishi UFJ and Sumitomo Mitsui have all been punished as hard or even harder than those US banks at the epicentre of the sub-prime debacle. The nagging fear is that Japan's lenders - the conduit for the world's greatest stash of savings - have taken on a far bigger chunk of mortgage securities, collateralised loans obligations and other exotica from America's structured credit boom than they have yet revealed. Americans and Europeans have so far confessed to $130bn of the estimated $400bn to $500bn of wealth that has vanished into the sub-prime hole. Somebody, somewhere, must be sitting on a vast nexus of undisclosed losses. We may find out soon enough whether the hold-outs are in Japan. The banks have to come clean under the country's strict new audit codes by the end of the tax year in March. What we know is that Japan's economy - still the second biggest in the world by far - has fallen over a cliff since October. It remains joined to America's hip after all. The decoupling theory has failed its first test. We tend to forget that Japan remains the world's top creditor nation by far, the shy master of fate. The country's net foreign assets of $3,000bn roughly match the net debts of the US. Where have the Japanese recycled the quarter trillion dollars they earn each year from their surplus? Official data shows that their holdings in US Treasury bonds have not risen. The Swiss offer us a clue, says Redeker. They are Europe's Japanese, champion savers looking for returns abroad. They devoured US sub-prime debt on a much bigger scale per capita than the Americans. Hence the $24bn in write-downs by UBS." If this is the case -and it does all make sense - it will make Europe look like a safe haven.
|
POSTED BY
ROBIN BOWMAN
ON
WED 20TH FEBRUARY
AT
08:21
|
|
RE: MADE IN AMERICA - WHAT THE GLOBAL SLOWDOWN MEANS FOR CEE – AND FOR PROPERTY INVESTORS
Great question - with a great reply. This discussion may seem a bit technical - but it is really important to understanding how the credit crunch will play out differently in different parts of the world... and therefore how that should impact on your property investment strategy.
|
POSTED BY
NEIL LEWIS
ON
WED 20TH FEBRUARY
AT
22:51
|
|
|
|
[ Back To Blog Home ]
|
|
CONTRIBUTORS
- Neil Lewis
- Robin Bowman
- Ben Greenwood
- Noreen Lucey
- Stanislaw Staromlynski
- Brett Tudor
- Panos Tsigaras
BLOG POSTS
Aug 2008
Jul 2008
Jun 2008
May 2008
Apr 2008
Mar 2008
Feb 2008
Jan 2008
Dec 2007
Nov 2007
Oct 2007
Sep 2007
Aug 2007
Jul 2007
DISCUSS
BOOKMARK THIS
|